www.quora.com/Is-it-ok-for-your-spouse-to-go-out-all-night-and-not-let-you-know-what-they-are-doing-or-that-theyre-ok-Do-you-expect-a-courtesy-call-if-theyre-going-to-be-home-at-4-am-or-are-they-grown-and-can-do-whatever-whenever/answer/Joreth-Innkeeper
Q. Is it ok for your spouse to go out all night and not let you know what they are doing or that they're ok? Do you expect a courtesy call if they're going to be home at 4 am or are they grown and can do whatever, whenever, without any concern for you?
A. Since my spouse lives 5,000 miles away, I would find it very odd indeed if he gave me a courtesy call to let me know that he would be home at 4 AM.
Aside from that, though, I think the question is loaded. When I have lived with partners, I do not expect a call telling me what their plans are. They are grown adults and can make their own choices.
I would not say this is “without any concern” though.
If, for some reason, I had an *expectation* that they would be home at a certain time, then I would expect a courtesy call because that’s what courtesy is. If a live-in partner told me that they would be home for dinner and I was making dinner for the both of us, I would be both irritated and concerned for their safety if they did not come home reasonably close to the time they said they would.
If my partner has a regular and predictable schedule, and they failed to come home at a time that it would be reasonable to assume or expect that they would be home, I would probably be concerned for their safety.
If my platonic friend promised to meet me for coffee one day and didn’t show up, I would be concerned about the friend. If my sister said she would call me tonight to talk about our plans to give our parents an anniversary gift, and she didn’t call me, I would probably be concerned about her. If my coworker was supposed to have a business meeting with me and didn’t show up, I would probably be concerned about them.
If I have an expectation about the whereabouts of another person, the first thing I would do is examine if that expectation is reasonable. If that expectation is reasonable (i.e. they *said* they would be there and they’re not), then I would be concerned. But I do not generally expect people to keep me notified of their movements and behaviours unless those impacted me directly. My partners’ schedules are not mine to keep. Their time belongs to them. That’s part of what makes them autonomous human beings.
I eat my meals when I want to eat. I go to bed when I want to sleep. I wake up when I need to wake up. None of those things require a partner’s presence. My partners can come and go as they please, providing they are meeting their obligations and are considerate of how their actions affect other people.
Which is the expectation I would have of *anyone* I was dating and living with, dating and not living with, or living with and not dating. When I moved back in with my parents after college, my sister playing loud music in the room next door when I was trying to sleep was inconsiderate. It didn’t matter that she was my sister, we were sharing space. If a partner did the same thing, he would be equally inconsiderate.
And, likewise, I did not keep my sister’s schedule and had no idea what she was doing or where she was unless it was relevant for me to know. We often talked to each other about our lives outside of home, just because we love each other and sharing is a form of intimacy, but I had no *expectation* of knowing her schedule. We just talked to each other because that’s what people do when they like each other.
A partner would be no different. If my sister was supposed to be home for dinner so that she could wash the dishes, I would have been very irritated for her to not show up and do her chores. Same with live-in partner. But while she was out? Whatever, she’s capable of making her own decisions about how to live her life. Same as my partners.
It’s not without *concern*, it’s without *expectation* and with respect for their autonomy. Their time and their lives and their decisions belong to them. How those things impact *me* is when it becomes reasonable for me to have a say in them, insofar as the impact that I will allow. My partners can stay out all night if they want, but if I come home to make dinner for us and they keep not showing up, that’s wasting my time and efforts, so I can choose not to keep coming home and making dinner if they’re not going to respect my time and efforts.
If my expectations continue to mismatch with the reality of their behaviour, then *I* am the one with a choice to make - either adjust my expectations to match or leave the relationship to find someone who is a better match.
So, yeah, my partners can go out all night and not let me know ahead of time what their plans are. But it’s not without concern, it’s just without expectation.
Q. Is it ok for your spouse to go out all night and not let you know what they are doing or that they're ok? Do you expect a courtesy call if they're going to be home at 4 am or are they grown and can do whatever, whenever, without any concern for you?
A. Since my spouse lives 5,000 miles away, I would find it very odd indeed if he gave me a courtesy call to let me know that he would be home at 4 AM.
Aside from that, though, I think the question is loaded. When I have lived with partners, I do not expect a call telling me what their plans are. They are grown adults and can make their own choices.
I would not say this is “without any concern” though.
If, for some reason, I had an *expectation* that they would be home at a certain time, then I would expect a courtesy call because that’s what courtesy is. If a live-in partner told me that they would be home for dinner and I was making dinner for the both of us, I would be both irritated and concerned for their safety if they did not come home reasonably close to the time they said they would.
If my partner has a regular and predictable schedule, and they failed to come home at a time that it would be reasonable to assume or expect that they would be home, I would probably be concerned for their safety.
If my platonic friend promised to meet me for coffee one day and didn’t show up, I would be concerned about the friend. If my sister said she would call me tonight to talk about our plans to give our parents an anniversary gift, and she didn’t call me, I would probably be concerned about her. If my coworker was supposed to have a business meeting with me and didn’t show up, I would probably be concerned about them.
If I have an expectation about the whereabouts of another person, the first thing I would do is examine if that expectation is reasonable. If that expectation is reasonable (i.e. they *said* they would be there and they’re not), then I would be concerned. But I do not generally expect people to keep me notified of their movements and behaviours unless those impacted me directly. My partners’ schedules are not mine to keep. Their time belongs to them. That’s part of what makes them autonomous human beings.
I eat my meals when I want to eat. I go to bed when I want to sleep. I wake up when I need to wake up. None of those things require a partner’s presence. My partners can come and go as they please, providing they are meeting their obligations and are considerate of how their actions affect other people.
Which is the expectation I would have of *anyone* I was dating and living with, dating and not living with, or living with and not dating. When I moved back in with my parents after college, my sister playing loud music in the room next door when I was trying to sleep was inconsiderate. It didn’t matter that she was my sister, we were sharing space. If a partner did the same thing, he would be equally inconsiderate.
And, likewise, I did not keep my sister’s schedule and had no idea what she was doing or where she was unless it was relevant for me to know. We often talked to each other about our lives outside of home, just because we love each other and sharing is a form of intimacy, but I had no *expectation* of knowing her schedule. We just talked to each other because that’s what people do when they like each other.
A partner would be no different. If my sister was supposed to be home for dinner so that she could wash the dishes, I would have been very irritated for her to not show up and do her chores. Same with live-in partner. But while she was out? Whatever, she’s capable of making her own decisions about how to live her life. Same as my partners.
It’s not without *concern*, it’s without *expectation* and with respect for their autonomy. Their time and their lives and their decisions belong to them. How those things impact *me* is when it becomes reasonable for me to have a say in them, insofar as the impact that I will allow. My partners can stay out all night if they want, but if I come home to make dinner for us and they keep not showing up, that’s wasting my time and efforts, so I can choose not to keep coming home and making dinner if they’re not going to respect my time and efforts.
If my expectations continue to mismatch with the reality of their behaviour, then *I* am the one with a choice to make - either adjust my expectations to match or leave the relationship to find someone who is a better match.
So, yeah, my partners can go out all night and not let me know ahead of time what their plans are. But it’s not without concern, it’s just without expectation.